Friday, September 26, 2008

Frustrations and reflections

Part I: Frustrations
Why is it acceptable to make fun of a group of people because of their political beliefs? Is it all right for an instructor to make value judgments about some of his students by saying that he is "proud to be voting for the first African-American presidential candidate"? Even if meant in jest, is it right to make derogatory comments about people of a particular political persuasion? What really bothers me is that these jokes and comments were made in the context of a larger conversation about tolerance of race and religion in the public schools. If someone had made a joke about a minority ethnic or religious group, there is no way that would be tolerated in class. But, as someone told me during the break last night, "it's cool to make fun" of Republicans. The atmosphere in that class last night made me very uncomfortable and irritated. I almost walked out, but thought that would have been an unproductive way of handling the situation.

Let me be clear: the free exchange of ideas between people is one of the cornerstones of our democracy. I think I have proven myself to be good-humored about these issues, and I am not the type to whine and complain about being discriminated against. Some of my favorite people in the program are the people with whom I disagree about virtually everything political. I welcome the opportunity to discuss, debate, and wittily banter with those on the other side of the aisle. But I do not think that it is appropriate for instructors to create the kind of hostile setting I encountered last night. Eugenie was right in thinking that the University might not be a "safe place" for conservatives to express their views. It certainly has not been for me, and it has never been worse than it was last night.

I'd love to get some thoughts on this from MACers of all political persuasions. What should I do about this?

And just for the record: I believe that the nomination of an African-American as the presidential candidate of a major party in the U.S. is historic and important. It shows that this country really has come a long way - and we have seen in this campaign, unfortunately, that we still have a long way to go. I would vote for an African-American in a heartbeat if he reflected my philosophy of government and I felt he would lead the country in the direction I think is best. I do not feel this way about THIS candidate, and therefore I will not vote for him. But if he were a conservative (or even not a Marxist...), I'd vote for him in a second. That is why I resent the implications of some of the comments made last night.

Part II: Reflections on my placement
For everyone in the social studies small group meeting last night: I love my mentor as a person. He is great to talk to, and he is one of the most brilliant men I have ever met. His older students love him because of that intelligence. However, I disagree vehemently with the way he approaches his classes of younger students. This has created some awkward situations for me, because I do not feel that it is my place to make judgmental comments about someone's teaching. I think the situation will improve as the year progresses, and I am not going to give up on that class and those students. Besides, I'm way too attached to the kids at this point to make any kind of move.

A very strong positive about my mentor is the effective way in which he integrates technology in the classroom. Every lesson, for the freshmen and the juniors/seniors, is driven by a PowerPoint presentation he creates. He downloads CNN Student News to iTunes and shows that to his freshmen fairly regularly. We had an activity the other day where students were able to respond to test questions with "clickers" - basically little remotes - handed out to each individual. My mentor encourages his students to type their papers and do their homework with the online version of the book. He is also the go-to guy in the department when his colleagues are struggling with technology. Technology in his classroom is not always flashy, but it is a useful tool that he expertly uses to complement his teaching.

10 comments:

msauter said...

Your comments concerning the atmosphere of last night's class, I think, are insightful. Trying to truly live the doctrine of tolerance is rather difficult, because it involves accepting the views of those who may vehemently disagree with this doctrine and who are perceived as incredibly intolerant. There have been a few ridiculous comments made over this past week (e.g. blanket generalizations about "right-wing radicals," intelligent people voting for Obama, Leon's comment, etc). I understand that many of the liberal or democratic persuasions are passionate about their views. All I ask is that anyone who professes these views be consistent. If someone promotes tolerance and diversity, then that one shouldn't just pay lip-service to "tolerating even Republicans," but actually have respect for the views of people that might radically differ from one's own. And this especially applies to a classroom setting in which tolerance and open dialogue are held up as standards.

MGoDan said...

Well, are well appreciated. Certainly, I don't consider my a tolerant person. Now, i'm going to have to explain that.... basically, at first contact, i tolerate anyone and everyone. that is, until they open their mouths. then my opinion of them tends to go waaaaaay downhill. of course, this applies to the average person and therefore not to anyone in our cohort. so, in sum.... i'm not intolerant of those of different appearances/cultures. i am, however intolerant of ignorance and stupidity and uhhh... intolerance applied to appearance, etc.

The other thing is this: i don't feel bad about the discussion from the other day for 2 reasons: 1) we're all adults and closer to peers than not. anyone can express their thoughts in these classes with impunity, IMO. 2) when it comes to intolerance of political views, no one is forced to be a leftist, rightist whatever. people are not born one way or the other. you make that choice. so, basically... intolerance of race/ethnicity/religion != intolerance of political persuasion.

MGoDan said...

i need a good editor.

KOZMONAUT said...

I'm totally with you Bobby! Perhaps the most troubling comment was..."young Republican? Isn't that an oxymoron? So is smart Republican." OUCH! And that was said by one of the site coordinators!! As some of my students say, "tots inaprop" (totally inappropriate).
I hope Eugenie really makes a bulletin board for SOE that even-handedly represents both candidates' positions!

Autumn said...

Hi Bobby,
I am really sorry that you felt uncomfortable in class, because I don't think that is right... however, that being said, I agree with Dan, and in the fact,that we are all adults. Thus, in my opinion, we should stand up for own rights and call people out on what they say. I know that you are doing that in your blog, but I think mentioning it in class would have been valuable as well and perhaps would have started an important conversation.
Autumn

Chris and JJ said...

Hey Bobby-
I think it is somewhat funny that Michigan holds itself to the highest of standards. (How many times have we been told, "You guys are the best of the best" or "We are at the University of Michigan (italics on that)) Yet I bet I can go to other colleges and not be exposed to constant political viewpoints. I find it almost refreshing when I venture outside of Ann Arbor and see McCain stickers. You mean there is someone running against Obama?

Anonymous said...

I'm gonna go out on a limb and disagree with you, Bobby. I might regret it because it might start an argument with you, but hopefully it can be a friendly argument through which perhaps I can offer you a perspective on how the situation looked from my angle.

I didn't see the comment the way you did, and maybe it is because I am not a conservative, and maybe it is not, and no, I am not taking his side because I am not a conservative. However, I don't think he meant to imply that those who do not support Obama are not doing so because they are racist. I don't truly believe that because you do not support Obama that the field instructor in question or any other liberal thinks you don't support him because he is black.

I think said field instructor was just expressing that he, like you, feels America has come a long way in that we finally have an African American presidential candidate. I can see how you could have taken his comment the way you did, because he said he was PROUD to vote for an African American--which could, I suppose, be interpreted to mean that those who are not must not be. Nonetheless, I think he was simply saying that he was proud of America for coming such a long way and finally having an African American nominee (and that he also happened to be voting for him).

That being said, he could have said, "I am proud that America has come so far as to have an African American presidential nominee," and left out the part where he said he would be voting for him. Still, I don't think he was accusing those who don't support Obama of being racist.

To be sure, there are still some very racist people out there, and those people probably do not support Obama for that reason. Still, I don't think that was what he was getting at.

Also, with regard to his comment that Laura noted in her comment, I agree that that was inapprop. But I don't think Leon thinks you are racist.

On this same note, I only ask that we try not to make generalizations about neither liberals nor conservatives. I personally do not feel very positively about being lumped into a category of intolerance. Never have I ridiculed someone for their beliefs, conservative or otherwise. Not all of us are, as you have so eloquently put it, Bobby, "psycho liberals."

Jeff Stanzler said...

Bobby, I want to start by saying thanks to you for addressing this topic. Look at the conversation that your posting engendered! Liz and I could only have hoped that important teaching issues would be raised (and, I should add, raised in a respectful manner) in the blogs, so we're grateful to you.
I'll only add that your comments remind us all of the importance of our platforms as teachers. Dan adds the important reminder (as I interpreted it) that just because we as teachers say something, doesn't mean that our students morph into our political clones. However, I think we'd be deluding ourselves to forget that there's a power dynamic in our classrooms, and that the maintenance of a safe environment for expression of a range of ideas demands continual care on our parts. One of the cool things about teaching, especially in public schools, is the likelihood that our students will come from a wide array of backgrounds, including political beliefs. Ultimately, a big decision that we need to make, and then enforce, is what kind of environment we want to have in our classroom? Your comments have led to some thoughtful amplifications and rejoinders, and it's clear that all of you are seeing some of the nuances here at an early enough juncture to be able to use those insights in setting the tone for *your* classes come January.
Thanks, Bobby.

Maria said...

Ohhh Bobby... reading your comments about politics reminded me about the politics going on between teachers and the strikes going on at certain school districts!

I have never been a big fan of politics, but I would like to know more about the situation going on with teachers at Wayne Westland and the strikes. I do feel sad that students are being pulled out of schools because adults cannot make a decision that will appease both sides while not having students miss out on school experiences!!

Anyways, let me know if you have any thoughts on the strikes! I would be interested to hear :)

Meghan said...

I think we should also note that for the first time a woman is running for vice president. This means that if McCain is elected, there is a chance she will be the first female president (if he should die). So, no matter who wins, it will be historic.