So said Mr. Madison, one of the most brilliant men in American history. He also said that the first cure for faction is to remove said liberty, a cure that he rightly noted is "worse than the disease."
Disagreements and debates are deeply sewn into the fabric of humanity, and it is natural that the political sphere would be a space for some of their most impassioned manifestations. Nobody is going to agree about everything (or, in some cases, anything). This is not a negative; in fact, this is what keeps our Republic moving. People have different visions of our government's role in our lives and in the world, and many of these differences have become glaringly obvious during the protracted 2008 Presidential campaign.
I'm a big fan of the civil exchange of ideas over these issues. But I do believe that what the process is sorely lacking is a modicum of respect. It is not uncommon to hear statements like, "You're voting for Obama? You must hate capitalism" or "Why would you vote for McCain? We're going to invade 87 more countries in the next 4 years if he get elected." While unproductive, this discourse permeates our politics from the grassroots to the chambers of Congress. Clearly, our next President will not destroy the American economic system or try to conquer the world. But behind the negative, exaggeratory rhetoric are real issues that have been obscured by the hate and name-calling. Wouldn't it be a much nicer country for everyone if we placed more value on education and discussion and less on telling the other side how stupid and out of touch they are?
It is important to remember that there is more than one perspective. As teachers, one of our roles is to get students to think about sources - who wrote it? Why was it written? What agenda did this person have? We must remember to do the same thing in our own lives. The United States has great diversity of opinion, and most of them are legitimate and valid (even when they disagree with yours). People who grow up in one area are going to have a different political perspective than those who grew up in another. This doesn't make either group stupid; it is what makes the process awe-inspiringly beautiful.
I was driving through my hometown on the way to church on Sunday, and almost every lawn had a sign proclaiming a candidate's name. I passed a McCain sign, then an Obama sign, McCain again, Obama right after. This might make me a huge nerd, but I got goosebumps as I thought, "I love democracy." My beliefs and biases have become quite clear to everyone at this point, but we should remember that it is the PROCESS we can all rally around. No matter who wins the election tomorrow, I legitimately hope that our next President leads our country toward a brighter future at home and abroad. None of this "I'm moving to Canada if [insert candidate here] gets elected!!" The United States is a great country in part because we may disagree with the policies of our President - but he or she is still our President.
Make sure your voice is heard.
VOTE!!
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
LOVE IT!!! I totally agree. I voted today and got goosebumps and a little teary-eyed. NERDS UNITE!!
No matter what happens tonight, it exciting to see so many people energized and mobilized!
Ok, so a little after the election but ready for it...I agree with everything you said! I would also add, that despite what one may think of a particular person's policies, the office needs to be respected. We must look so stupid to other countries right now because of the way many people treat/discuss/mock/degrade the president. Maybe as social studies teachers we can work to inspire this respect in our students and figure out ways to fully convey how wonderful democracy is!
Ok, so very late, but totally agree. Sometimes it would be nice to make a list of all the things everyone has in common, because in the end we are all in this together.
Post a Comment