Yesterday, while I was at my placement, a student got kicked out of class. This is really no surprise, as something like this happens almost every day. This particular student gets thrown out a lot, so the fact that it was him was also no surprise. Additionally, he didn't actually DO or say anything to warrant being kicked out... also no surprise. These things are almost a daily occurrence with this particular student. After a student is sent to the hallway, my mentor teacher or his co-teacher usually goes out to talk to him/her before letting him/her back into class.
Since this happened while the students were doing an individual activity, I decided to go out and talk to this student myself. I have developed a pretty good relationship with him since September, and I wanted to see how he would respond to me and my style as opposed to my mentor's. During our conversation, I asked him what he thought about our class, and his response was essentially: "I hate it because of the teacher." It is clear to me that he has some anger issues, and he is not always able to keep his feelings inside when someone upsets him. He told me he had been suspended almost 40 times the previous year for similar types of infractions (mouthing off, etc.). I know this student does not have the greatest home life, from previous conversations with him. I told him that if he ever felt the need to "vent" because of something that happened in class, he could feel free to come up and do so to me, no penalties. He seemed amenable to this arrangement, and I thought the whole experience was simultaneously amazing and heartbreaking.
The point of this story is to highlight what we all know already: YOU DO have an impact on your students. It's not just about how well you teach government, biology, Spanish, whatever. A student will like your class if you like and respect them. If students feel you are unfair, or pick on them too much, they will hate the class (as evidenced by my experience yesterday). I am trying to bring this student back into the fold by asking for his opinions and help, rather than telling him what to do and yelling at him all the time. So far, he has seemed to respond far better to me than to other teachers who are less patient with him. He continues to challenge me, and I hope I am up to the task of answering these challenges as he presents them.
I definitely don't have all the answers for these kinds of situations, but I do know that if you don't have respect for your students at the foundation of your pedagogy, you will probably be climbing an uphill battle when you try to engage them in the course material.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
5 comments:
I absolutely agree with you Bobby. RESPECT is fundamental in teaching your students. However...what I have learned from being in a class where it is all about respect and not about discipline is that you have to have a middle ground. Just like anything, extremes are dangerous. The students have been taking advantage of the lack of discipline in the past month or so. I still would like to visit your classroom some time since it sounds like the complete opposite of mine.
Kristin is correct about the balance between respect and discipline being so hard to find sometimes. I usually don't have trouble getting the students to trust me, but I am fairly certain they like to push the boundaries because they think I might be a pushover. And sometimes I am. Sigh.
I wish I had more time to visit around. I too would like to see your class (and Kristen's) to see different ways of figuring this all out.
Give it! Get it! haha :)
I agree with all that you said about respecting the students. It just takes time for them to see that you respect them for them to give that respect in return. I had some hardships with students at the beginning because they didn't know me well enough yet, so they tested me a lot. Now, the same students who gave me a hard time ask about me when I am not at school. It really is true that they won't respect you just because you're their teacher, and especially not just because you're their STUDENT teacher. It takes time to earn their respect because you need to show them that you deserve it because you respect them as well.
Well put Bobby, and good work getting through to your students!
Bobby, I think that this student has helped you to realize something that is VERY important to being an effective teacher, and to (frankly) maintaining the desire to stay in the classroom for a while. There are many ways in which teachers frame the issue of the importance of reciprocal respect, but I tend to think that it works better when it is named and discussed.
You also have framed a somewhat delicate challenge for yourself...how to establish your own distinct identity while being careful not to convey the message that you're the cool one and the mentor is, well, not. Knowing you, I am sure that you would be cautious and conscious on this front, but it's another domain where the challenges of interpersonal relationships and communication require thoughtful action.
That is awesome you got to see the impact you're leaving on your students. That's HUGE! I also have a question for you... what have you been doing in your history class in regards to current politics? Did the students get a chance to watch the inauguration in school? I remember that my history classes always focused on what we were learning, and I felt that I missed out on the current events. I hope your teacher does cover the current happenings within our country and that the students are interested!
Post a Comment